Jump to content
Check out our typography channel on Instagram

The honest YouTube Sans reviews

Ralf Herrmann


YouTube’s new font family “YouTube Sans” is designed to be used in both product and marketing communications. It currently makes its official debut in their newest product YouTube TV. Here is what type designers have to say about it.

YouTube Sans was created by Saffron in partnership with Letterjuice in Barcelona and URW++ in Hamburg. Unfortunately, Saffron’s presentation page for the project rather feels like a sales pitch—or a parody of such presentations. We see typical clichés like adding construction circles to the finished artwork. Almost funny are the following images, that honestly want to draw a connection between the rounded YouTube play button and the execution of the YouTube Sans letters, such as the G. You know that this would be true for the vast majority of typefaces, right? And the tension of the specific arcs isn’t even similar. 

rounded.png

12-Col-White-box-animation-21.jpg

But all this marketing talk aside, what about the type design itself? Currently YouTube Sans comes in several upright weights. The overall look of the design isn’t anything spectacular. A modern sans-serif design leaning towards geometric designs, which are very popular currently. So its not really a bold choice, but the execution does have a subtle uniqueness, which could certainly be sufficient to serve the branding requirements of a custom font.  

 youtubesansbold.gif

Youtube_Saffron_09.jpg

But type designers have critizized the execution of the design. 

Both looking at the details, like how arcs and stems meet, as well as how letters work together, the design doesn’t feel as consistent and professional as it could be. Its easy to point to successful retail typefaces in the same general sans-serif category with much better execution and visual consistency.

But the biggest flaw of the design is certainly the use of another branding cliché: randomly cutting off corners of letters. A trend so big, that has its own Tumblr feed as a “hall of shame”. 

Yes, its lazy and there is never an acceptable justification for it. Just because its so easy to do in your vector design app, doesn’t make it desirable. Stroke endings can take on many different shapes, but in the end (or on the end in this case), consistency is key. It goes back to the roots of typefaces in writing, where the stroke endings were a result of the writing tool and the angle one would hold this tool. Rounding or cutting off corners arbitrarily can only lead to an inconsistent and distracting appearance. Explaining it through the angles of the YouTube play button triangle might be a nice gimmick in a pitch, but it doesn’t do anything useful in the real-world use of the type family. 

youtubetv.jpg

YouTube Sans on the YouTube TV welcome page

You can see YouTube Sans in use here. The bold headlines do their job quite nicely. This is where your custom (display) font can shine. The legibility of the smaller text isn’t as good though. Google’s Roboto, recently rolled out on youtube.com works much better in such cases. It will be interesting to see how these different typefaces will be used and possibly combined in the future. 

What’s your opinion on YouTube Sans? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comment section below. 

Links:




  • Like 4


User Feedback

Recommended Comments

Bjørn Edvard Torbo

Posted

Yeah, it's not great. I flat out despise the slanted terminals, especially in the G, H, I, J and N. I can sort of live with the E, F, f and t. Great comments and insights from Spiekermann, Phinney and Hoefler. 👍



Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Check out our exclusive articles, videos and font downloads on Patreon!
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We are placing functional cookies on your device to help make this website better.