"Giving one typeface away for free will most likely only booster sales, and it's a good deed."

[Dunwich Type]

To me it comes across as both “preachy” and “asking”.

Seconded. A clearing house for high-end F/OSS fonts is one thing. A dogmatic manifesto is another.

@Eric: You make many good points, and if you can put all that together, you should follow it up with a good essay explaining why type designers should be the ones responsible for solving the web-fonts conundrum and why letting people derail web fonts with the piracy strawman is a waste of time.